19 Best Etsy Gifts: Unique Ideas To Support Small, Sustainable Giving
Gifting is good for you. Literally. That’s what science says.
But what if you give a gift that supports a small business AND will be used for years to come?
Now that’s a gift that keeps on giving.
No sustainable store is better for shopping small than Etsy—but is Etsy good for gifts?
When it comes to unique handmade gifts, Etsy is hands-on the best resource,
With countless items by talented creators across every niche and budget, you get the ultimate gift-buying experience—all while supporting small, independent makers and shipping with carbon-neutral delivery.
And thanks to Etsy’s new sustainability rags, finding the best eco-friendly Etsy gifts has never been easier.
We’re here to make it easier still with our own list of the best sustainable Christmas gifts on Etsy in 2023.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. We may receive a small commission if you make a purchase through a brand link below. Learn more here.
The Full List Of The Best Etsy Gift Ideas For 2023
Best Etsy Christmas Gifts
1. WEmade Boutique
Price Range: $6–$25
As much as we’d love to give all our gifts in person, it’s not always practical.
Remotely-gifted eco-friendly Etsy Christmas gifts and birthday gifts aren’t complete without a card and a handwritten letter.
A sustainable Christmas or Hanukkah card from WEmade Boutique keeps the celebration going long after, either by becoming a field of wildflowers or a keepsake.
Enclose a gift card or voucher in each one and it becomes its very own zero waste gift wrapping.
Or maybe your gift is that you’re hosting this year’s family Christmas party. In that case, the Confetti Seed Paper Hearts are on-point sustainable Etsy Christmas gifts for both you, your loved ones, and the earth.
2. Altered State Studio
Price Range: $13
These weighted cotton crackers are some of the best eco-friendly Christmas gifts on Etsy as they can be reused as part of the gift recipient’s holiday celebrations year after year.
Not to mention their festive themed designs will complement any place setting.
3. Marissa Kay Apothecary
Price Range: $4–$375
If you’re looking for simple sustainable Etsy Christmas gifts for coworkers, the plantable seed paper cards by Marissa Kay Apothecary are an understated yet classy option.
These rustic cards are available in everything from holiday and birthday themes to thank you and generic vintage botanical prints for any purpose.
Buy their bulk packs to make sure you always have an eco-friendly card on hand for whatever occasion arises.
Each piece of handmade paper is packed with wildflower seeds specifically designed to attract pollinators—making these sustainable Etsy gift ideas all the more sustainable.
Price Range: $13–4$0
Candles are an all-time classic Christmas gift—and sustainable candles in particular are some of the best sustainable Etsy Christmas gift ideas that never disappoint.
beEsom makes candles in all shapes and sizes—pillars, tealights, jars, votives, spheres, and more—but what they all share in common is that they’re made of 100% organic local beeswax.
You can’t go wrong with an organic beeswax candle in an amber glass jar with a cork lid. They come in a variety of holiday-themed (for the pumpkin spice lover in your life) and traditional scents.
For loved ones who prefer candle warmers to open flames, beEsom’s offers adorably-shaped beeswax melts too.
Best Etsy Gifts For Women
5. Shine Skincare Co.
Price Range: $14–$85
What is a gift on Etsy almost every woman will love?
That’s easy—the thoughtful gift of healthy, glowing skin!
For that, you can’t beat Shin Skincare Co’s all-natural, powerful skincare products.
We’re absolutely in love with their range of natural face serums. Depending on our skin’s need, we use one just about every day.
Our go-to is the Soothe + Hydrate – Face Serum. Complete with hyaluronic acid, algae extract, and snow mushroom extract (which is 400x as moisturizing hyaluronic acid!), it harnesses the power of nature’s unique and powerful ingredients.
Though we have pretty sensitive skin, it’s always soothed and never irritated—making this a safe Etsy gift idea for friends for all skin types.
Plus, your gift purchase will help Shine give a part of it to the domestic abuse support organization, WEAVE.
6. Dab Herb
Price Range: $3–$240
Perfect for stockings or “just because”, the makeup singles and sets from Dab Herb are clean and conscious—by which we mean cruelty-free, vegan, non-toxic, and palm oil-free.
Many of the ingredients that go into their eco-friendly makeup and skincare are organic, wildcrafted, and/or food-grade.
The five-piece Organic Make-up Set is one of the best sustainable Etsy gifts for ladies who like to keep their beauty routine clean and simple.
All products come in metal or glass and select items can be refilled, making these zero waste gifts, too.
7. B Blane Designs
Price Range: $
The best sustainable Christmas gifts from Etsy help us support a fairer and more equal world—which is why B Blane Designs offers jewelry without all the ethical issues.
Handcrafted by owner Barbara in Northern Ireland, this shop turns recycled sterling silver and 9K gold into nature-inspired rings, nose studs, earrings, and necklaces.
The Molten Silver Swing Style earrings are one-of-a-kind, created through liquid metal that turns out designs “unique as your fingerprint”.
And you can really up your ethical Etsy gift game by pairing it with its matching pendant.
Barbara also offers bespoke designs if you have a specific sustainable Etsy Christmas gift idea for friends and family.
8. For Strange Women
Price Range: $8–$150
Cruelty-free and one-of-a-kind scents like Black Forest, French Oakmoss, and Decadence and Debauchery make these truly unique eco-friendly Etsy holiday gifts.
Depending on your giftee’s preference, you can select the Solid Perfume Gift Set (with four scents)—each of which come in pocket-sized sample tins—or go big with the Perfume Oil Full Sample Collection of 13 scented oils and a fixative base.
Both the oils and solid perfumes are handmade and free of palm oil, phthalates, parabens, and synthetic ingredients.
9. Praxis Jewelry
Price Range: $30–$1,594
Of all the sustainable gifts for her, nothing is quite as ever-lasting as something that shines.
Recycled gold, silver, brass, and platinum make up most of the rings, bracelets, necklaces, and earrings, though some are accented with lab-grown or ethically sourced gemstones.
Their hand-hammered Cuff Bracelets can be personalized with any name or phrase you choose, a sure contender as one of the best sustainable Etsy Christmas gifts for your friends or siblings.
The Distressed Stacking Rings—available in a choice of metals to suit—are a simple and elegant piece your loved one will be able to wear for any occasion.
Best Etsy Gifts For Men
10. Aura Que
Price Range: $5–$146
Consider a pair of uber-comfortable ethical slippers.
For him or her, Aura Que uses hand-felted techniques out of raw sheep wool and natural buffalo suede sourced from a small family tannery.
The bright array of available colors is all thanks to azo-free sustainable dyes.
Making these eco-friendly Etsy gift ideas more eco-friendly, designer Laura Queening uses any waste yarn in other products.
Based in the UK, she works with small producer groups in Vietnam and Nepal. The artisans are paid fair wages within a World Fair Trade Organization-certified collective.
11. Always the Adventure
Price Range: $4–$30
Brainstorming eco-friendly Etsy Christmas gift ideas for friends who are outdoor enthusiasts?
Always the Adventure takes one of the climbing community’s retired aids—old ropes—and breathes new life into these life-saving extensions.
Their Recycled Rope Can Cozies (which have almost entirely five star reviews) will snugly fit that organic beer or can of La Croix, dressing it up in an ever-revolving range of fun colors and patterns.
If that special climber isn’t much of a can drinker, the shop’s other recycled ropes products can hold plenty of other things, too—like their adorable Recycled Climbing Rope Caddies, designed to hold anything from keys to your favorite sustainable tea sachets.
Or, if you’re looking for a more personalized gift that doesn’t quite fit with their offered products, drop them a note and see if they can custom create what you need.
12. Imperium Shaving
Price Range: $27–$156
Zero waste razors may sound like unusual Etsy gift idea for him, but the eco-minded will appreciate how much plastic waste one of these babies cuts away.
While the non-eco-minded will appreciate how much they’ll be saving by saying au revoir to disposable razors.
For one that actually looks like a gift, Imperium Shaving razors feature a slick chrome head and an FSC-certified sustainable wood handle.
Opting for a razor set with a stand included will help your gift recipient keep their razor properly stored and clean.
If you’re looking for groomsmen gift ideas, they have sets for that as well!
Each one is handcrafted in the USA, supporting independent artisans and small-town roots.
Best Sustainable Etsy Gifts For The Home
Price Range: $25–$125
Especially if you opt for the big and beautiful Colorful Abstract area rug, made with natural dyes and 100% flat woven wool.
If a rug won’t quite fit in your loved one’s life, they offer plenty of other eco-friendly Etsy gifts for the home—like the cotton and linen Colorful Contemporary Kilim Throw Pillow Cover.
The Egyptian social enterprise incorporates their culture and rich history in the designs while supporting artisans with fair wages.
14. Simply Chi
Price Range: $12–$2,250
What is the best thing to buy on Etsy for the home?
It simply must be Simply Chi.
If you’re looking for unique and sustainable Etsy Christmas gifts, their vintage home decor is unmatched.
They’re not only a sustainable way to keep existing items in circulation, but each piece tells a story.
You’re not just giving a gift; you’re giving a piece of history.
The well-loved pre-loved shop focuses on boho, eclectic, earthy postmodern pieces from the 1980s and 1990s, which includes a carefully curated collection of decor, planters, lighting, furniture, wall art, office items, dinnerware, and barware.
Their ever-rotating stock has a little something for everyone, from sustainable stocking stuffers and small Etsy Christmas gifts ideas for coworkers like a set of vintage owl salt and pepper shakers, to larger items like this natural stick hanging mirror curio box.
15. Chase Vintage
Price Range: $29–$3,950
With 200+ unique Etsy gifts available sourced from all around the world, you’ll be able to find everything from interesting decor to practical home goods—such as cutting boards, crockery, tea kettles, and hand-carved wooden bowls.
This makes them the perfect go-to for Etsy unique wedding gifts and holiday gifts alike.
For instance, the bread-baker in your life may just love one of their many different rustic wooden breadboards available.
If you find the perfect gift, remember to act fast, because the one-of-a-kind vintage nature means they might not be available for long.
Price Range: $11–$76
For some truly unique gifts on Etsy, you’ve got(tles) to check out Gottles.
They take beautiful glass bottles—wine bottles, liquor bottles, and more—and transform them into something more beautiful still, like light fixtures and recycled plant pots.
Have a whiskey-lover in your life?
Spice up your usual Christmas gift of a special bottle by giving them a bottle of a different sort—by which we mean the Maker’s Mark Whiskey Pendant Light, which will look perfect lighting up their collection.
Gottles operates for the purpose of diverting items from the landfill, so these Etsy sustainable gifts also give back a little bit to the planet.
Best Sustainable Etsy Holiday Gifts For Kids
17. Finch & Folk
Price Range: $7–$119
Kiddos aren’t exempt from benefiting from some of the best gifts from Etsy.
Enter: Finch & Folk and their selection of organic baby toys made from materials like non-toxic painted beechwood or 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton—as in their soft and stimulating collection of Organic Soft Block Rattle Toys.
For extra little ones who are just entertained by their toes as toys, opt for one of their non toxic play mats.
Plus, anything from Finch & Folk is also a thoughtful gift to parents everywhere, knowing their new presents won’t expose them to harmful chemicals.
18. A Childhood Store
Price Range: $12–$95
The best sustainable Etsy Christmas gifts for kids might just be those that keep them occupied the rest of the day while mom and dad prepare dinner.
For that, look no further than A Childhood Store and its selection of non-toxic, earth-safe art supplies.
Kids can transport themselves to another world in their recyclable cardboard Color Your Own Princess Castle.
Of course, they’ll need something to do the coloring with so be sure to add one of A Childhood Store’s handmade soy or beeswax crayons. They’re available in various shapes and sizes to suit a range of ages.
19. LisLis Toys
Price Range: $9–$99
Both are made from unfinished, sustainably-sourced wood and are designed with no sharp corners or edges so playtime is safe from every angle.
Did you know we Have a Newsletter?
We cover the latest in sustainable living, fashion, zero waste, beauty, travel, finance and more…
How We Chose The Best Eco-Friendly Etsy Gifts
Finding gifts on Etsy is easy as can be, but how did we find gifts on Etsy that are sustainable, too?
First and foremost, the best Etsy gifts for friends, coworkers, kids, and whoever all have two things in common; They’re made of high quality and consciously designed to last as long as possible.
Oh, and that they can actually be useful and treasured, rather than tossed before next year’s Christmas tree is cut.
The best sustainable Christmas gifts on Etsy are also those made of sustainable materials including those that are natural and compostable. That or second-hand or recycled materials that don’t add more stuff to the world.
Ethical Etsy gifts are also important, and fortunately, most Etsy sellers are solo or work on small teams, practicing andmaking and made-to-order techniques—yet more ways to prevent wasted products and unnecessary machine emissions.
Final Thoughts On Unique Etsy Gift Ideas
Gifting makes us ecstatic (er, Etsy-static?). Gifting plastic-laden junk that ends up in a landfill shortly after it’s unwrapped?
Not so much.
A better alternative that will really one-up Santa is one of these environmentally friendly Etsy gifts. With these, you’ll be showing you care not just for your loved one, but for small businesses and the planet alike.
If you know someone who’s struggling with their shopping this holiday season, consider sharing this Etsy gift guide with them—or perhaps our guides on gifts for vegans or gifts for minimalists depending on gift giver preferences.
Maybe they’ll even take the hint when shopping for you 😉