11 Indianapolis Thrift Stores You Don’t Want to Nap On
When you think of Indianapolis, you probably think of racetracks, the Indy 500, or the Colts.
But what about Indianapolis thrift stores?
Indy is a fast city with breakneck trends, eclectic tastes, and a bustling culture.
That’s why we’ve curated the best thrift shops—along with some thrift shopping tips to put you on the fast track (of the Indy Motor Speedway, of course) to success—so you can find slow fashion stability amongst the movers and shakers.
1. Naptown Thrift
About Naptown Thrift Store Indianapolis
Naptown Thrift is the quintessential spot for vintage clothing.
Don’t let the humble brick exterior fool you—inside this Indy thrift store is an eclectic collection of carefully curated apparel with walls lined with vintage art, posters, and memorabilia.
The clothing racks are brimming with 80s and 90s Disney and Looney Tunes graphic tees, denim jackets, funky hats, handbags, and statement jewelry.
Whether searching for a new outfit or simply browsing for inspiration, it’s easy to lose yourself in the packed aisles.
If you can’t make it in person, you can check out their online store, too.
Naptown Thrift isn’t just a place to shop—it’s a community hub where locals gather to share their passion for fashion and sustainability. Their welcoming atmosphere creates connections, conversations, and collaborations.
Overall, Naptown Thrift is a great place to find unique pieces and like-minded individuals.
Location: Canterbury-Chatard
2. Broad Ripple Vintage
About Broad Ripple Vintage Thrift Shop Indiana
Broad Ripple Vintage is a real hidden gem.
Step inside and take a journey through fashion history—racks adorned with pieces dating back to the 1920s all the way to the 1990s. Each item has a distinct story, making each piece one-of-a-kind.
From flowy, vibrant dresses to tailored suits, Broad Ripple Vintage casts a broad net when it comes to men’s and women’s apparel.
You’ll see vintage denim, statement jackets, quirky sunglasses with gold mirrored lenses, unique jewelry, and other accessories lining the shelves.
One of the reasons we love Broad Ripple is that they purchase various second hand garments from the community, having a rippling effect in encouraging folks to not only buy second hand, but dispose of old clothes more responsibly, too.
Location: Broad Ripple
3. Audrey’s Place
About Audrey’s Place Furniture Thrift Stores Indianapolis
Audrey’s Place Furniture has existed for over 40 years, making it a beacon of the Indianapolis community.
It’s easily one of the best furniture thrift shops in Indianapolis, where you can find distinctive pieces infused with character.
The charming storefront is just as charming as the interior—inside, you feel welcomed, warm, and like you’re walking through multiple time periods.
The showroom showcases a curated selection of furniture spanning various styles and eras, from mid-century modern classic chest of drawers to ornate Victorian pieces.
They cater to a diverse array of tastes and sensibilities, which has helped them be a pillar of the community.
Moreover, with so much history, you can guarantee the staff at Audrey’s Place knows a thing or two about vintage furniture. The store is renowned with countless positive reviews of knowledgeable staff members ready to lend a hand.
Location: Near Eastside
4. Vintage Kulture Clothing
About Vintage Kulture Clothing Indianapolis Thrifting
Vintage Kulture Clothing stands as a vibrant ode to the timeless allure of retro fashion and individual expression. Locals praise it as one of the best thrift stores in Indiana for its affordable prices, selection, and helpful staff.
Vintage Kulture blends nostalgia and modernity with a curated selection of tees, sweaters, denim, bombers, jackets, hats, and accessories.
You can shop online and find stand-out pieces like a retro Budweiser Zip-Up.
Each item in the boutique is handpicked by the staff for its craftsmanship, character, and timeless appeal.
Location: Near Southeast
5. Mission 27 Resale
About Mission 27 Resale Shops Indianapolis
Mission 27 Resale, nestled in the heart of the city, stands out amongst other shops for its dedication to raising funds for good causes.
Run by the volunteer organization Society of St. Vincent de Paul, they serve the disadvantaged by raising funds for food pantries and Changing Lives Forever—a program teaching people how to lift themselves out of poverty.
Mission 27 carries countless one-of-a-kind pieces, like clothing, housewares, accessories, furniture, and everything in between. Whether you’re looking for a new-to-you minimalist plaid sofa sofa or sustainable Christmas decorations, you’re in good hands.
If you can’t make it in person, Mission 27 also has an eBay store for online shopping.
Location: Leota St | Bates-Hendricks
6. Consigned by Design
About Consigned by Design Consignment Stores Indianapolis
When it comes to Indianapolis consignment shops, many turn to Consigned by Design as a role model for how to operate.
It’s a premier destination for shoppers seeking high-quality, gently used furniture and home decor. The upscale consignment shop’s interior can be described in a few words: clean, welcoming, and warm.
Upon entering, you’ll see countless pieces that blend luxury, sophistication, and affordability.
Consigned by Design carries something for every room, like chic accent chairs, designer lamps, hardwood dining sets, and other decor knick-knacks and collectibles.
Each item is meticulously vetted for quality, ensuring only the finest pieces find their way onto the showroom floor.
The best part is you can shop online and pick-up your piece within 48 hours. If you’re looking to sell, they make it easy by clearly stating what they do and do not take.
Location: Castleton
7. Zodiac Vintage
About Zodiac Vintage Indie Thrift Shops
Are you looking for wacky and weird second hand treasures?
Look no further than Zodiac Vintage.
The charming bright, teal door and display windows will welcome you inside where you’ll find a host of carefully curated vintage clothing and accessories.
Think: 70s denim, aged leather jackets, colorful blouses, stand-out tees, and chunky accessories—everything you need to put together a killer outfit to hit up Monument Circle.
Plus, Zodiac regularly hosts pop-ups and events, which are posted on their Instagram for easy access.
Location: North Square Neighborhood
8. JBP Furnishings
About JBP Furnishings Furniture Consignment Shop Indianapolis
JBP Furnishings is locally renowned for its exceptional, gently-used furniture and home decor.
Walking into JBP Furnishing is like entering a sophisticated, safe haven where second hand pieces spend their glory years.
The showroom is phenomenal, with meticulously arranged displays showcasing an impressive array of elegant dining sets, exquisite rugs, striking artwork, and seating of all shapes and sizes—like a plush royal blue sofa to add a pop of color to your living room
There’s also a fair selection of hard-to-find vintage pieces.
The staff is committed to delivering the best customer service and is willing to lend a hand for whatever comes up.
Location: Garfield Park
9. Midland Arts & Antiques Market
About Midland Arts & Antiques Market Indianapolis
With gadgets and gizmos aplenty, Midland Arts & Antiques Market is one must-stop thrift shop.
They have a simple description, “Large, multi-level warehouse stocking furniture, housewares & collectibles from decades past,” but inside is so much more.
You’ll notice the scent of old books and polished wood as you walk through displays of rare collectibles, retro furniture (powder blue vintage papasan chair, anyone?), porcelain home decor, vintage jewelry, and other intricate pieces.
You’re sure to find one, two, or a few items that suit your tastes. Even if you don’t purchase anything, walking through Midland Arts is always a treasure hunt with hidden goodies tucked away in every corner.
Location: Holy Cross
10. NobleCause Resale
About NobleCause Resale Shop Indianapolis
NobleCause Resale has been serving its community for nearly 35 years.
And since it’s operated by the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, 85% of sales go to the food pantry.
Inside this Indy thrift store, you’ll notice a clean, welcoming interior with an ever-changing catalog of second hand goodies—exquisite gold trimmed dining sets, all manner of clothing, furniture, home decor, and other unique finds.
NobleCause sets itself apart through inclusivity, accessibility, and striving to create a welcoming space where everyone feels valued and respected.
Friendly staff members are always on hand to assist with any concerns.
Location: Noblesville
11. The Toggery Resale Boutique
About The Toggery Resale Boutique Indianapolis
Near the White River, you’ll find The Toggery Resale Boutique.
From earning $3 on opening day to a 4,000-square-foot boutique, The Toggery has come a long way. It carries the lackadaisical, trendy, and elegant style of Broad Ripple Village with a vast selection of second hand women’s clothing.
The consignment store carries blouses, dresses, footwear, handbags, accessories, designer pieces, and more.
The friendly staff makes it easy for anyone to sell their items and it’s equally easy to find your next outfit for a night out at The Quarter by shopping online.
Be sure to follow their socials, too, for not only updates on the latest items, but also for unique outfit inspiration. We certainly wouldn’t have thought to pair a Joje ruffled white blouse, bright orange blazer, and leopard print skirt together but they make it WORK!
Location: Broad Ripple
Did you know we Have a Newsletter?
We cover the latest in sustainable living, fashion, zero waste, beauty, travel, finance and more…
Why Thrift Shop At The Best Thrift Stores In Indianapolis?
Indiana is behind the national average, with a recycling rate of 21% compared to 32%. But that isn’t the only reason you should go thrifting in Indianapolis.
Finding high-quality, second hand pieces that have stood the test of time helps you avoid fast fashion junk.
These unique garments can spice up your style and reflect your taste without becoming tattered in three months.
Even though Indianapolis is the racing capital of the world, it’s more important than ever to adopt a slow fashion mindset to curb the astronomical amount of textiles and home furnishings we’re dumping in landfills each day.
Final Thoughts On Indy Thrift Stores
That’s the checkered flag on our racetrack roundup of the best thrift stores in Indianapolis that really lap the competition, but there are countless other treasures to find all over Naptown.
If you don’t find what you’re looking for in these boutiques, you can always talk to friends or search online marketplaces for unique pieces.
Or you can shop at online second hand stores and have preloved duds delivered directly to your door.
So start your engines, send this list to your favorite thrifting buddy, and race over to one of these gems next time you need something “new”.
Pin these:
